0012657: Unclear how bonuses stack - DEV Arcen

ID	Project	Category		Date Submitted	Last Update

0012657	Bionic Dues	Note To Test		Sep 23, 2013 1:49 am	Sep 26, 2013 1:28 am

Reporter	GrimerX	Assigned To	keith.lamothe
Status	closed	Resolution	fixed
Product Version	0.919

Summary	0012657: Unclear how bonuses stack
Description	I'm assuming this is how it works: Base sensor range is 18 +1 from part -> 19 +8% -> 20.52, rounded down Why is the 8% being applied? This isn't a shield part, or a shield stat AFAICT See attached screenshot, I'll add a savegame too in case it's useful...
Tags	No tags attached.

Internal Weight	For New Player Experience

GrimerX Sep 23, 2013 1:49 am reporter	2013-09-22_00001.jpg (361,388 bytes)

GrimerX Sep 23, 2013 1:50 am reporter	Game.save (5,978 bytes) 5,_0919,2,1,1515,69,4,154,25,125,1,36,6fd94a14-05f8-49d7-a5f6-41907a2bbca7,1,62,3,31,1,0,0,0,1,1,6,Grimes,1567734606,4,1,1909090586,838,3,4,11,1,6,1,21,1,0,0,3,0,0,0,1,2,2,0,0,3,0,0,0,1,47,3,0,0,3,1,97,2,-5,1,1,0,0,0,6,18,5,0.1600,3,8,3,33.00000,4,3,2,4.00000,4,7,4,2.00000,5,12,1,0.1326,4,17,0,0.0700,2,1,46,3,16,1,1,0,0,0,1,20,0,6.00000,4,0,1,55,4,0,0,2,0,0,1,43,5,0,0,2,0,0,1,61,6,0,0,2,0,0,7,2,6,1,2,7,0,0,3,0,0,0,1,3,8,0,0,3,0,0,0,1,51,9,0,0,1,0,1,55,10,0,0,2,0,0,1,43,11,0,0,2,0,0,1,59,12,0,0,3,0,0,0,8,3,6,1,6,13,0,0,3,0,0,0,1,1,14,0,0,3,0,0,0,1,47,15,0,0,3,0,0,0,1,55,16,0,0,2,0,0,1,43,17,0,0,2,0,0,1,61,18,0,0,2,0,0,1,4,6,1,16,19,0,0,3,0,0,0,1,1,20,0,0,3,0,0,0,1,47,21,0,0,3,0,0,0,1,57,22,0,0,1,0,1,41,23,0,0,4,0,0,0,0,1,59,24,0,0,3,0,0,0,125,4,104,3215,1423,0,0,4,34,39,60,86,3,59,1392,661,0,0,3,95,113,122,11,88,1826,2200,0,0,3,24,25,125,10,49,2387,819,0,0,3,47,50,123,13,111,828,897,0,0,4,54,55,56,92,13,61,2728,2260,0,0,3,30,31,106,7,11,1410,1942,0,0,3,9,10,15,5,91,970,1316,0,0,4,17,23,40,43,16,123,2285,975,0,0,3,47,49,114,6,53,77,737,0,0,3,52,75,76,16,37,3739,1437,0,0,2,35,38,16,101,2646,1009,0,0,2,48,100,19,118,1277,1081,0,0,3,42,43,93,16,63,1891,1469,0,0,4,16,41,45,117,3,107,69,2085,0,0,2,4,7,15,55,933,781,0,0,4,56,58,97,111,18,28,2399,2000,0,0,3,25,30,105,6,7,331,1937,0,0,4,3,5,107,19,8,67,1853,796,0,0,4,65,66,68,102,3,69,1666,690,0,0,4,65,68,70,94,2,21,253,1406,0,0,4,20,108,22,109,12,43,1057,1125,0,0,4,56,91,92,118,16,119,631,693,0,0,5,54,76,77,97,110,3,44,2342,1469,0,0,3,36,62,100,17,79,600,342,0,0,3,78,80,120,17,32,3307,2000,0,0,1,31,11,125,2122,2322,0,0,2,25,88,5,24,1577,2186,0,0,3,88,89,26,14,100,2543,1211,0,0,5,44,48,99,101,115,6,52,133,974,0,0,4,53,74,75,109,3,72,1677,387,0,0,2,70,71,18,83,1271,261,0,0,3,82,85,103,20,121,1185,404,0,0,3,73,82,95,5,115,2751,1297,0,0,3,36,39,100,12,68,1890,640,0,0,3,51,67,69,2,18,681,1545,0,0,3,17,20,23,2,19,209,1731,0,0,3,7,90,108,11,102,1989,790,0,0,3,51,67,114,22,77,682,565,0,0,3,97,119,120,9,64,1585,1197,0,0,3,41,42,65,10,39,3089,1250,0,0,4,38,48,104,115,12,36,2677,1466,0,0,4,44,86,115,124,5,117,2095,1537,0,0,3,45,62,63,5,34,3269,1617,0,0,3,60,86,104,11,97,871,631,0,0,4,55,58,77,119,7,51,2015,639,0,0,4,50,68,70,102,5,66,1943,945,0,0,3,46,67,98,6,9,1100,1948,0,0,4,10,11,12,13,16,112,965,391,0,0,3,73,81,96,2,96,829,481,0,0,3,80,112,120,4,16,1715,1580,0,0,4,15,41,63,27,2,57,640,1112,0,0,3,23,74,92,19,75,275,826,0,0,4,52,53,76,110,11,124,2484,1658,0,0,3,36,62,87,3,113,1529,590,0,0,3,59,70,71,11,4,212,2195,0,0,2,1,107,21,86,2976,1475,0,11,4,33,34,36,104,15,90,482,1639,0,0,3,6,19,20,15,15,1511,1693,0,0,4,11,13,14,16,15,110,435,889,0,0,3,54,75,119,21,106,2521,2104,0,7,3,30,61,105,3,13,1224,1776,0,0,3,9,15,17,20,116,2057,1196,0,0,2,45,98,7,82,1075,305,0,0,3,83,84,121,10,20,429,1498,0,0,4,18,21,90,108,22,30,2397,2213,0,0,3,28,61,106,21,12,957,1919,0,8,3,6,8,9,6,5,574,2008,0,0,5,2,3,6,7,8,6,6,746,1861,0,0,3,5,12,90,8,45,2144,1364,0,0,4,63,99,116,117,16,3,362,2107,0,0,3,1,7,5,1,60,3474,1474,0,0,3,34,35,104,16,74,324,1085,0,0,4,22,52,57,109,18,58,1087,668,0,0,4,55,73,97,122,18,71,1522,440,0,0,4,72,95,103,113,4,27,2110,1824,0,0,3,16,26,62,6,50,2178,729,0,0,3,49,51,114,3,26,1839,1971,0,0,3,24,25,27,7,78,483,532,0,0,3,76,79,120,17,1,335,2256,0,0,3,2,3,4,17,89,1303,2295,0,0,2,10,24,22,87,2700,1712,0,0,3,33,105,124,10,38,3396,1280,0,0,3,35,37,39,20,14,1251,1561,0,0,3,15,17,40,7,41,1778,1304,0,0,4,16,63,64,98,5,122,1251,735,0,0,4,56,58,59,93,19,48,2785,1161,0,0,3,39,100,101,3,65,1671,971,0,0,4,64,67,69,94,6,95,1304,462,0,0,3,59,71,121,12,42,1403,1165,0,0,3,40,64,118,16,46,2120,1000,0,0,3,66,99,114,22,31,3161,2202,0,0,3,29,32,61,2,109,57,1176,0,0,4,21,22,52,74,21,25,2054,2146,0,1,4,26,28,88,125,16,56,1137,886,0,0,4,43,55,111,122,3,80,736,233,0,0,3,79,81,96,10,108,131,1525,0,0,3,19,20,21,14,98,1875,1130,0,0,3,41,66,116,11,33,2958,1660,0,0,3,29,86,87,17,62,2322,1708,0,0,4,27,44,117,124,4,17,926,1567,0,0,4,13,14,18,91,10,105,2593,1903,0,0,4,28,29,87,106,5,114,2200,859,0,0,4,46,50,102,123,4,99,2310,1209,0,0,4,45,46,47,100,12,76,423,687,0,0,4,53,75,78,119,22,40,1279,1369,0,0,3,14,42,91,2,29,2778,1978,0,0,3,31,33,105,7,94,1450,844,0,0,3,65,69,93,12,84,1035,148,0,0,3,81,82,85,3,85,1176,128,0,0,2,83,84,14,35,3630,1650,1,0,3,37,38,60,13,47,2500,1027,0,0,3,49,99,123,20,10,1139,2170,0,0,3,9,89,11,11,103,1463,301,0,0,2,71,83,10,22,311,1272,0,0,3,21,74,109,9,73,1096,526,0,0,3,58,112,121,8,70,1776,516,0,0,4,51,69,72,113,2,92,833,1064,0,0,3,43,57,111,20,93,1320,945,0,0,3,94,118,122,9,81,883,252,0,0,3,80,84,112,14,120,638,455,0,0,4,77,78,79,96,18,54,621,839,0,0,3,110,111,119,3,2,485,2188,0,0,3,1,5,8,10,8,811,2055,0,0,3,2,5,12,13,23,745,1288,0,0,3,18,91,57,9,55,1,2,1,1,0,0,0,1,14,0,4.00000,4,4,4,20,1,1,0,0,0,0,74,13,-5,1,2,0,71,0,3,15,0,0.0800,3,7,0,1.00000,1,18,0,0.1200,1,78,14,-5,1,2,0,23,0,3,16,0,0.0800,3,11,0,2.00000,1,7,0,1.00000,1,104,15,-5,1,2,0,59,0,5,16,0,0.0600,1,15,0,0.0600,1,17,0,0.0600,1,19,0,0.0600,1,7,0,1.00000,1,48,16,128,1,3,21,31,0,3,11,0,3.00000,2,7,0,1.00000,1,9,0,10.00000,6,47,17,128,1,3,0,27,0,1,8,0,68.00000,10,103,18,-5,1,3,50,27,0,6,16,0,0.0600,1,15,0,0.0600,1,17,0,0.0600,1,19,0,0.0600,1,14,0,4.00000,4,8,0,23.00000,1,49,19,128,1,3,0,72,0,2,9,0,6.00000,1,18,0,0.2800,9,0,8,63,20,-5,1,2,0,43,0,2,1,0,0.1921,5,12,0,0.1226,1,53,6,-5,1,4,86,0,1,3,13,0,8.00000,6,21,0,11.00000,1,26,0,6.00000,5,65,7,-5,1,4,18,7,1,3,1,0,0.1921,5,6,0,2.00000,5,2,0,0.2500,1,56,21,10,1,4,73,0,0,3,14,0,7.00000,7,11,0,3.00000,2,20,0,4.00000,2,102,22,-5,1,4,69,31,0,4,19,0,0.1100,6,7,0,1.00000,1,18,0,0.1400,2,9,0,6.00000,1,70,23,-5,1,4,0,20,0,3,12,0,0.1416,6,14,0,1.00000,1,6,0,2.00000,5,103,24,-5,1,3,0,60,0,4,16,0,0.1000,5,15,0,0.0600,1,17,0,0.0700,2,19,0,0.0700,2,83,25,-5,1,3,57,0,0,3,17,0,0.1100,6,20,0,3.00000,1,16,0,0.0700,2,0,12,15,7,16,11,21,9,12,14,20,18,17,22,0,5,49,0,56,325,100,7,51,1,49,37,0,54,4,4,23,36,4,35,20,4,11,30,4,2,46,4,2,45,1,0,0,0,0,0,0,1,2,2,0,1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,0,0,2,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,-1,0,0,75,0,4,0,0,0,0,1,1,0,0 Game.save (5,978 bytes)

Chris_McElligottPark Sep 25, 2013 9:52 am administrator ~0034030	Keith, I'm not sure what to do here.

keith.lamothe Sep 25, 2013 2:18 pm administrator ~0034049	It's probably working fine; the 18 => 20 means that your overall stat will go up by 2. That is, that the exo as a whole will get more than +1 due to bonuses present elsewhere. But I'll take a look when I get a chance.

keith.lamothe Sep 26, 2013 1:08 am administrator ~0034063	Yea, I took a look at your save, and this is working as designed. Sensors is a computer stat, and your science exo (the one pictured, I believe, since it has 12 base sensor range) has an inherent +50% boost to computer stats. It's base sensor range is 12, which means it's effectively 18 due to the bonus. When you add +1 the base becomes 13, which +50% is 19.5, which is then rounded up to 20. The "+8% to All Shield-Related Stats" line is not relevant in this case because it sensors is not a shield-related stat, as you pointed out :) Anyway, if you think something needs to be done feel free to re-open this, but I'm not seeing any bugs, or any obvious way to make the situation clearer (it could show more info, sure, but that would probably be a net loss of clarity).

GrimerX Sep 26, 2013 1:26 am reporter	stat_calc_breakdown.png (226,168 bytes) stat_calc_breakdown.png (226,168 bytes)

GrimerX Sep 26, 2013 1:28 am reporter ~0034064	I also couldn't think of anything simple that would be useful. I just attached an image from Crusader Kings II which is the closest in comparison I could think of. In CKII having that level of detail is both useful and necessary. For Bionic Dues, I think it would be useful, but not as necessary. I'll proactively agree this is not for 1.0 :-) Just wanted to log the idea anyway.

Date Modified	Username	Field	Change
Sep 23, 2013 1:49 am	GrimerX	New Issue
Sep 23, 2013 1:49 am	GrimerX	File Added: 2013-09-22_00001.jpg
Sep 23, 2013 1:50 am	GrimerX	File Added: Game.save
Sep 23, 2013 3:59 pm	tigersfan	Internal Weight	=> For New Player Experience
Sep 23, 2013 3:59 pm	tigersfan	Assigned To	=> Chris_McElligottPark
Sep 23, 2013 3:59 pm	tigersfan	Status	new => assigned
Sep 25, 2013 9:52 am	Chris_McElligottPark	Assigned To	Chris_McElligottPark => keith.lamothe
Sep 25, 2013 9:52 am	Chris_McElligottPark	Note Added: 0034030
Sep 25, 2013 2:18 pm	keith.lamothe	Note Added: 0034049
Sep 26, 2013 1:08 am	keith.lamothe	Note Added: 0034063
Sep 26, 2013 1:08 am	keith.lamothe	Status	assigned => closed
Sep 26, 2013 1:08 am	keith.lamothe	Resolution	open => fixed
Sep 26, 2013 1:26 am	GrimerX	File Added: stat_calc_breakdown.png
Sep 26, 2013 1:28 am	GrimerX	Note Added: 0034064